Nook/Kindle Dilemma

I got a Sony Reader for Christmas, but decided to exchange it for a reader that I could synchronize with my iPhone. I have been using the Kindle app for almost a year and thought that was what I wanted. However, when I did just a little research, I discovered the Kindle cannot download library books and that was a very important feature for me. The Barnes & Noble Nook does library books and purchased books, has a large selection of free books on Barnes & Noble’s website, and also has an sync-able app for the iPhone, so I decided to go with that. I made my exchange at Walmart on December 30.

After setting up my Nook account, downloading a few books from both the B&N website and the Phoenix Digital Library, and having the Nook in my hands for several hours, I began to have second thoughts about the product and kept thinking about that smaller, thinner, lighter-weight Kindle. The inability to access library books nagged at me less and less, and the more I held the Nook in my hand, the less satisfied I became. I decided to exchange it for a Kindle.

Today I cleared my account from the Nook, reset the factory settings, and took it back to Walmart. When I presented it at the customer service counter, the clerk told me e-readers may only be returned within 14 days of purchase. I am 10 days too late.

Now I want a Kindle, but cannot return my Nook. And now I know how Daryl felt when he got his MDX.  At least I know he finally became happy, so I probably will, too. I have found that your perspective usually changes when your options vanish.

This entry was posted in Life & Family. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Nook/Kindle Dilemma

  1. Mom says:

    Oh, dear! You thought it was 30 days. I’ll let you read my Kindle once in a while, when I’m not using it (which is a rare occasion–only when I’m reading Miss Julia books from the library).

  2. Lisa Stieg says:

    Well, I suggest you put a fabulous library book on there and I bet you’ll feel better about it! The Kindle really is a great device. I’ve not used the Nook reader, but I bet in time you’ll be happy with it. Did you get the color version?

  3. Donna says:

    Oh Lisa, that’s such a smart idea!

  4. Donna says:

    Dilemma solved! I took the Nook to Walmart tonight prepared to beg my case with a manager, but the gal at the return desk didn’t even bat an eye, just gave me my money back. I’ve ordered my Kindle.

  5. Daryl says:

    I know I like my Kindle a lot, and it’s a generation older than yours will be. Did you get the 3G version, or Wi-Fi?

    There are lots more books available for the Kindle than Amazon has, and many of them free or at least cheaper than Amazon. When you get it, I will give you some links.

    By the way, this blue on starry black color combo for comments is very hard to read, even after having my secondary cataract removed.

  6. Donna says:

    Yeah, I don’t like the popup comments box on this theme, but I like the cold winter scene for January. Two ways you can get around it: Click on the post title (instead of the home page or comments link) and see the comments below the entry; or use a blog feeder/reader.

    BTW, I got the 3G. I don’t feel the need for Wi-Fi. Someday I’ll have an iPad to do all the web surfing I want on a “purse-size” device.

  7. Daryl says:

    Or I can just highlight the text in the comments to make them readable.

    What’s the ETA on your new Kindle?

  8. Donna says:

    I did free shipping, so ~5-7 days. I look for it by the end of the week.

  9. Donna says:

    It arrived today!

  10. Daryl says:

    So how is it? Downloaded anything to read yet?

  11. Donna says:

    I had several books already downloaded to the app on my iPhone, so I just sync-ed my account. I spent the evening reading the User Guide. I like it! I have to decide what to do about a case/cover. Don’t want anything too heavy or bulky.

Comments are closed.